Hattitude and Plagiarism


Photo TROMBONE© Chris Johnson from Dreamstime.com



I've noticed that people are often accused of plagiarism in the knitting world. I wonder if it's more common than in the literary world?


Several years ago I was teaching a workshop class for a hat design that most of my advisers said was too complex to do as a pattern. I ran the class at my guild the DKC and at my LYS Village Yarns. I called it Hattitude. Recently one of the previous students approached me with a copy of Cathy Carron's new book of the same name. She came to me just as I was about to start teaching so we only spoke for a moment but I got the impression that she was upset on my behalf feeling that I had been ripped off in some way. I later googled Hattitude and got 107,000 hits.


I've read a number of posts on Ravelry where people feel that their original idea has been stolen and they are angry.


I don't feel that way at all. I look at everything! art, fashion, nature, craft, the Internet and every other possible source that might fuel inspiration. I know that my memory is faulty and that while I won't remember the source it all gets muddled up in my brain and pops back out in a different format. I think of it like music all the notes are the same but are placed in an unique order. Or writing a novel ...all of the letters and words already exist but have been rearranged to make something new.


I also feel that if it's a good idea someone else is also just as likely to see that good idea as I am.


So lets not assume plagiarism or suspect it has happened. Everyone out there working in the knitting community all sees the same stitch dictionaries, the same books and magazines. There are only so many ways to wrap knitted fabric around the human body so of course some standard silhouettes will be used over and over again. The Internet is also bringing us contact with Knitters all over the world and that's going to have an impact as well. Lets not assume that anyone is trying to steal our ideas and realize that they are on their own creative path that might just intersect with our own in some way.


Lady in Waiting (or always have an easy knitting project ready to go)

This is the first day I've not been to the hospital. My Dad had his surgery last Sunday after falling on the previous Friday morning. My sister and I have been everyday. We've realized we can't keep that up so we are now going separately on alternate days. Unfortunately he is in a hospital in the far east end of the city and I live in the west end so the commute has been a major time suck.

Tomorrow my good friend Wanda will be driving me there and if things go well we will go out afterwards for dinner and a movie. Last Sunday I had brunch out with a group of friends and when I got to the hospital later I realized it really is true that you need to distance yourself for a least short periods of time, after having decompressed with them I really felt recharged and as though I had more resources to deal with the situation.

Last year after our first hospital experience with him I kept an outfit on a hanger at one end of my closet so that I could always get dressed at a moments notice if we got another emergency call. I never thought to make sure I would have knitting as well. This time I was just about to start a new knitting project so I grabbed that and took it with me. I did the swatches while sitting with him waiting for the surgery. Unfortunately I could not deal with working out the numbers for the sample. Instead I decided it's time for a simple project so I'm now working on what my husband has dubbed the Lady in Waiting Scarf. It's one step up from a plain garter stitch pattern and I had to put markers in to keep track of a K1, P1 row!!!!!!

Ouch, It's amazing how being stressed knocks out basic intellectual capabilities. I even messed up on the K1, P1 rows. I can tell my eye was looking for something cheerful. I pulled a solid orange and variegated pink, orange and yellow yarn out of my stash to work on. It will be a long scarf that can be wrapped around your neck more than once.

I sent 3 interview requests out today so I hope to get back to posting on the blog this week and will post an interview if anyone gets back to me by Wednesday.

An Interview with ...Stefanie Japel





Once a week I post interviews with interesting designers about their insights on their experience of working in the Knitting industry. I’ve noticed that every designer makes their living in a slightly different manner bringing their own unique presence to the Knitting world.





Where do you find inspiration?
I find inspiration by thinking about what's lacking in my closet! I usually create patterns for things that I'm knitting for myself or for my daughters. When I'm working on a book or pattern booklet, I think about one main concept, and then try to come up with offshoots of that main idea. My end goal (when working on a book or booklet) is to have a set of designs that create a collection. The designs share some similar features or a commonality of concept.

What is your favourite knitting technique?
I'm known for designing garments that are knit all in one piece from the neck down to the hem. I prefer to design raglan sweaters because I think that they fit better than sweaters knit in pieces and because I like being able to try on my knits as I go. I also have just found a real love of lace knitting. I've recently designed several shawls. I wouldn't have pictured myself as a "shawl person" but now that we live in the South West, I'm into little knits that I can take on and off as the weather changes. It's really not cool enough here to justify a whole wardrobe of sweaters.

How did you determine your size range?
When I wrote my first book, Fitted Knits, I started most garments at a 32 inch bust and sized them from 48 to 54" bust. I determined that based on the size range that is typically requested when designing for magazines. When I wrote my second book (Glam Knits) I tried to size most of the sweaters to 54" bust measurements because i wanted to accommodate a larger range of sizes. I've actually received requests from some smaller women to even include more sizes on the smaller end of the spectrum...so if I do a third book, I'll probably even do a wider range of sizes.

Do you look at other designers work or are you afraid that you will be influenced by their designs?
I do look at other people's work. I think it's important to have an idea of what's going on in the industry and what the trends are. I tend to stick to my own sense of style, so I'm not worried about being overly influenced by another designer's work.

How do you feel about the so called controversy of "dumbing down" patterns for knitters?
This debate has been going on for years in one form or another. A few years ago, the debate was over whether there were too many patterns for novelty yarns, then too many patterns with big needles...then too many free patterns. It's always something. I really think that there's room for everyone. For every knitter there's a particular style of pattern writing that speaks to them. I think that people should be free to knit, write, and design the way that they want to. If a large number of knitters are requesting simplified patterns, designers will accommodate them. At the same time, I don't think that every designer should be forced to write simpler patterns.

How many sample/test knitters do you have working for you or do you do it all yourself?
I currently have three knitters that I call on at various times to help me complete projects. It's been hard for me to find knitters who take sample knitting seriously, so I keep my list very small.

Did you do a formal business plan?
I don't have a formal business plan. My business model has recently changed dramatically with the opening of my online knitting classroom (http://stefaniejapel.ning.com/). I've set up several goals for myself, and I do have long-range plans. It's been difficult for me to stick to a set timeline, because I've got two babies at home. One just turned two in January, and one is a newborn. I'm still trying to figure out how my days are going to work. Once I can get a grasp of exactly how many working hours there will be in a given week, I'll be able to be more specific about a timeline and what I think I can accomplish.

Do you have a mentor?
I have several people that I look to as mentors (though they may not even realize it!) I've been very lucky to sign on with the Stitch Cooperative (http://stitchcooperative.com/) are a group of women designers and businesspeople. They have been invaluable as a sounding board. It's been great to have a group of people to work with in getting my ideas out there.

Do you have a business model that you have emulated?
Because my business grew so organically on its own, I haven't really emulated another business. I started out as a blogger in 1999 and things just grew for me out of that. If I had to choose a business idol, it would be Jennifer Hansen of Stitch Diva Studios. Jennifer is a brilliant businesswoman.

What impact has the Internet had on your business?
Without the Internet, I'd have no business! I started online, my first patterns were published online, my shop is online, I teach online...everything is online!

Do you use a Tech Editor?
I do. I think that one needs another person's eyes on the math, and even on the formatting and writing, just to make sure that everything makes sense and looks as good as possible.

How do you maintain your life/work balance?
This is a really hard question. Before my daughters were born, I could just knit all the time, be online all the time, and go to all of the conferences and shows. But now, I really don't WANT to be online all the time, and I don't WANT to be away from my kids every weekend. I try to work late at night after they're asleep, and during nap times. I never want to ignore my kids in order to pay attention to what's happening on my computer.

How do you deal with criticism?
I hate to admit this, but I don't take criticism well. I tend to take negative comments really seriously and very personally. I think that because I love knitting so much, I tend to fall in love with my garments and so it's like some one's bad-mouthing a friend of mine. I totally ignore my Amazon.com book reviews because I think that people are so much more harsh online where things are pretty anonymous than they'd ever be in person. If I *do* run across a critique, I read it and then let it sit for a while before responding if it's something that needs a response. If it's not something that needs a response, I tend to just let it lie. I really am not a person who's going to get into a big public online argument.

How long did it take for you to be able to support yourself?
I decided to go into knitting full-time when I was pregnant with my first daughter. Fitted Knits had already sold 25,000 copies, and I was doing pretty well with online pattern sales. At that time, I'd been designing part - time for about 8 years.

What advice would you give someone who wants to pursue a career in knitting?
Before you sign any book contract, hire an agent.